It’s hard to manage your finances in two countries. You need two of everything, from chequing accounts to credit cards. Snowbirds need a U.S. bank account to take care of the bills at their condo. Canadian shoppers want easier ways to pay their Macy’s or J.C. Penney account after cross-border shopping sprees.
Opening an account at a U.S. bank is an option, but you might not be able to get a U.S. credit card because you don’t have a credit history. It’s also a hassle to get cash into those accounts because you either need a money order or have to cross the border, find a bank branch and deposit the cash.
Besides traditional Canadian snowbirds, there’s an increasing number of expatriates living and doing business in the U.S. who want more convenient banking access in both places.
Related: The ultimate guide to booking hotel rooms
Your credit choices come down to whether you want a U.S. dollar credit card issued by a Canadian bank, a U.S. dollar credit card issued by a U.S. bank, or a Canadian-issued credit card that doesn’t charge foreign exchange fees. Let’s explore those three options:
U.S. dollar credit cards
Most Canadian banks and credit unions offer some form of U.S. dollar accounts. Some offer U.S. dollar credit cards, allowing you to sidestep conversion rates and currency exchange service charges.
A U.S. dollar credit card is suitable for frequent travellers, cross-border shoppers, snowbirds, and online shoppers – anyone who makes purchases in U.S. dollars on a regular basis. Any Canadian resident can apply, as the requirements for obtaining a U.S. dollar credit card are the same as for any other Canadian credit product. Customers avoid the foreign exchange fee as well, since they can pay off their card in USD or CAD – whatever is convenient and makes sense from a foreign exchange perspective.
Best suited for: Individuals or small business owners who want to keep U.S. purchases and statements separate from their day-day-day banking in Canada.
U.S. issued credit cards
A U.S. credit card is a great way to ensure you can make purchases, pay bills, and get access to your money when you need it most. You can also avoid foreign transaction fees in the U.S. when you make spend and pay bills in the same currency.
Canadian residents must have an American address to apply for a U.S. domicile card. These credit cards are issued based on the applicant’s credit history in the U.S.
Related: Which bank offers the best rewards card line-up?
Both RBC and TD Canada Trust now offer accounts that overcome these hurdles, pairing them with a U.S. dollar credit card. They let you pay U.S. bills online, use American ATMs without access fees and make it easy to transfer money among the accounts. Dealing with banks with operations on both sides of the border is an advantage because they’ll help you leverage your Canadian credit history to obtain a credit card, mortgage loan, or line of credit.
If you plan on moving south for the long term, having a U.S. credit card is an excellent way to begin building your U.S. credit history.
Best suited for: Snowbirds, or those with broader ties to the U.S., who want to build and maintain U.S. credit history
No foreign-exchange fee cards
Trips to the U.S. and abroad also means dealing with foreign currency. You might think your credit card provider is doing you a favour by converting your foreign purchases back into Canadian dollars, but think again. Foreign currency conversion fees are often hidden within your credit card statement – blended in with the exchange rate so you don’t even notice you’re paying an extra 2.5% on your purchases. Don’t kid yourself – these charges add up in a big way.
Related: Best credit cards for travelling outside of Canada
Every major Canadian financial institution charges a 2.5% fee for foreign currency conversion on credit card transactions, a stiff penalty that cancels out any rewards you might have earned on your trip.
So what’s a traveller to do? Luckily, there are two great credit card options for Canadians who might look to save money on foreign travel as well as on items purchased online through foreign retailers.
Chase Card Services – a division of U.S. giant JPMorgan Chase but nothing more than a niche player in Canada – removed the currency conversion fee on its Amazon.ca Rewards Visa and Marriott Rewards Premier Visa. Customers using one of these cards will save the 2.5% foreign currency conversion fee when purchases are made in foreign currency.
Best suited for: Frequent travellers to the U.S. and abroad who want to avoid the 2.5% foreign exchange fee that most major credit card issuers charge.
If you’ve kept up with this blog for a while then you’ll know that I tend to prefer cash back to travel rewards. Unfortunately there aren’t a lot of options for earning big rewards from cash back credit cards. That’s why I was excited (and a little surprised) to see a new cash back card offering from BMO.
BMO Cashback World Elite MasterCard
The new BMO CashBack World Elite MasterCard offers unlimited cash back on everything you buy, no matter what spending category. The card pays a flat rate of 1.75 percent on all purchases – the highest base rate of any cash back card on the market. It also comes with a few other goodies, such as:
- Extended Warranty Plus – Which doubles the original manufacturer’s warranty period, up to a maximum of two additional years rather than the standard of one year.
- $0 Annual Fee for the first year – This offer is limited to new accounts. Applications must be received between May 13, 2015, and August 31, 2015. Full annual fee ($120) applies after the first year.
- Free additional cards – Add additional cardholders to your credit card account and earn even more cash back with no additional annual fee.
Your cash back rewards accumulate and automatically get credited to your statement annually (in January).
How does it compare?
When we last ranked cash back credit cards we looked at no-fee cards and annual fee cards to see how they each stacked up.
On $12,000 per year in spending, the BMO CashBack World Elite MasterCard pays $210 in the first year and then just $90 each year thereafter (after deducting the annual fee).
Conversely, the SimplyCash Card from American Express pays $307.50 in the first year and then $150 per year afterwards.
It’s clear the new BMO card is not meant for light spenders, as it would rank no better than 5th best in the no-fee, low spend category.
On $30,000 per year in spending, the BMO CashBack World Elite MasterCard pays $525 in the first year and then $405 each year thereafter (after deducting the annual fee).
The Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite – reigning cash back king in Canada – pays $732 in the first year and then $633 per year afterwards.
The new BMO card slides into the number 3 spot for best cash back credit card, trailing the Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite card and coming in slightly behind the SimplyCash Preferred Card from American Express (due to its generous 6-month bonus period and lower annual fee of $79).
Final thoughts
It’s great to see another solid cash back card offering, this time from one of the major banks. In a time where the best rewards cards seem to get discontinued at worst or watered-down at best, it’s a nice to have another rewards card paying more than 1 percent with no hassles or restrictions.
Still, it’s not enough to put the BMO CashBack World Elite MasterCard into the conversation of best cash back credit card on the market. But if you’re looking for a solid rewards card and don’t want the hassle of carrying multiple cards to use for groceries, gas, and travel, then this card is a decent choice.